What Could Be Wrong

Finds the claim the article rests on and lists the ways it could fail, ranked by how likely and how damaging, each with the evidence that would settle it. Calm and specific, never cynical.

What this template answers

Each item below becomes a heading in the AI response.

What is the load-bearing claim this piece depends on?
What would have to be true for it to hold, and which of those things does the text never show?
What are the most likely ways it fails, ranked by likelihood and by damage?
Who benefits if readers believe it exactly as written?
What evidence would settle each doubt, and where would you look for it?
How much of the headline survives if the weakest link breaks?

Creator

Maggern

What Could Be Wrong

Finds the claim the article rests on and lists the ways it could fail, ranked by how likely and how damaging, each with the evidence that would settle it. Calm and specific, never cynical.

Install Chrome extension

Creator

Maggern

What Could Be Wrong

What you get back

Thinking style

Settings

Library details

Perspective profile

Tags

Tags

Creator

Engagement

Meta

Try in Claude